Isabella Parkin (1902-1978) was apparently illegitimate. DNA evidence suggests her father was probably a son of my great grandparents Thomas Kirk (1846-1907) and Anne Guest (1848-1925).
Isabella was born in Rotherham (West Yorkshire). My great grandparents Robert Kirk and Anne Guest married in Rotherham and had children there, though Robert Kirk was born in Mattersey (north Nottinghamshire) and Ann Guest was born in Tipton (Staffordshire).
Isabella Parkin’s early life
Isabella Parkin was born on 30 December 1902 at 168 Middle Lane, Rotherham (Yorkshire). The birth certificate names her parents as Violet-Amelia Parkin (of 168 Middle Lane) and George Parkin (general labourer). Violet registered the birth on 26 January 1903.
Isabella was baptised on 21 January 1903 at All Saints, Rotherham (which became Rotherham Minster in 2004). The baptism register names her parents as George (labourer) and Violet Parkin, of 168 Middle Lane.
Her mother was Violet Amelia Parkin (1879-1956).
Was Isabella’s father really George Parkin?
Although Isabella’s birth certificate and the baptism register list her father as ‘George Parkin’, I have found no evidence that her mother Violet ever married. It seems likely that this George Parkin was invented.
There was indeed a George Parkin at 168 Middle Lane a few months before Isabella’s birth, but he was Violet’s father. When the 1901 census was taken, Violet’s father George Parkin was there with his second wife (Isabella Bach, later Steel(e)), 4 of Violet’s siblings and 5 of Isabella Bach’s children (and a visitor called Steel, perhaps related to Isabella’s 1st husband).
The 1901 census shows Violet Parkin (19) as a general domestic servant in the household of Anne Waile (74, living on own means) and her sister Emma Wood (56) at Rose Villa, Clifton Grove (Rotherham).
Violet and Isabella in the census
The census shows:
- in 1911, at 67 Pitt Street Holmes (Rotherham)—Violet Amelia Parkin (32, house keeper) with her brothers George Alfred Parkin (25, press worker), John Arthur Parkin (23, colliery [illegible word] repairer, above ground), Ernest Edward Parkin (21, machinist brass turner) and her ‘sister’ Isobella [sic] Parkin (8, school). All were born in Rotherham and were single.
- in 1921, boarding at 148 Peter Street, Kimberworth (Rotherham)—Violet Parkin (41y, 8 m, cook), Bella Parkin (18y, 5m, bookkeeper, ‘both parents alive’). They were boarding with John Thomas Harrison (26), his wife Margaret Ann and the Harrisons’ 2 infants.
A marriage between Isabel Parkin and George E Ripley was registered in Rotherham in the 3rd quarter of 1927.
The 1939 Register of England and Wales shows at 262 South Street
- George E Ripley (born 12 January 1899, steel annealing furnaceman, heavy worker, first aid ARP);
- Philip Ripley (20 August 1928 at school);
- 2 entries still redacted out
- Isabella Ripley (born 30 December 1902, unpaid domestic duties)
- Violet Parkin (born 22 January 1879, canteen attendant).
DNA evidence
My father has a DNA match with a great granddaughter of Isabella Parkin. The match comprises 5 segments of DNA, having a total length of 76 cM before weighting (40 cM after weighting). The longest shared segment is 21 cM.
It is conventional to measure the length of segments of DNA in centiMorgans (cM). If a matching segment is more than 10cM-20cM long, it is quite likely to be inherited from a common ancestor only a few generations back.
The DNA testing company Ancestry produces both a weighted measure of DNA (placing less weight on DNA segments that are common on the population) and a longer unweighted measure.
Isabella Parkin’s great granddaughter and my father both share DNA matches with:
- at least 3 descendants of my great grandparents Robert Kirk and Anne Guest. Those descendants share between 473 cM and 142 cM with my father, and between 43 cM and 25 cM with Isabella’s great granddaughter.
- a descendent of a brother of Robert Kirk’s mother Harriet Green, who shares 35 cM with my father and 25 cM with Isabella’s great granddaughter.
- someone who appears to be a 4 x great grandchild of Ann Guest’s grandparents John Whitehouse and Mary Darby. That person shares 15 cM with my father and 27 cM with Isabella’s great granddaughter.
- someone who descends from George Newton and Phoebe Capewell (of Kingswinford, Staffordshire). George Newton’s parents appear to be Isaac Newton and Elizabeth Guest, both of Kingswinford (Staffordshire). Could Elizabeth and/or Isaac be related to Ann Guest’s grandparents Thomas Guest and Ann (possibly Ann Newton, from Halesowen)? That descendant shares 11 cM with my father and 37 cM with Isabella’s great granddaughter.
- several other people whose ancestors I’ve not yet been able to link to any of my own ancestors.
Isabella Parkin’s great granddaughter shares DNA both with parents of Robert Kirk and with parents of Ann Guest, and I have found no ancestors common to both those sets of parents (of Robert Kirk and Ann Guest).
So, it seems likely that the unknown father of Isabella Parkin was a son of Robert Kirk and Ann Guest.
Which of Robert Kirk and Ann Guest’s sons?
The most likely candidates to be Isabella Parkin’s father are 2 sons of Robert Kirk and Ann Guest: Thomas William Kirk (1883-1966) and his younger brother John Kirk (1886-?):
- Thomas William Kirk was with his parents at 144 Greasbro Road (Rotherham) in 1901 and at 19 Weathill Street in 1911. He married Mary E Wilby (nee Goldborough) in the Rotherham area in the 1st quarter of 1918. https://birdsofcressingham.wordpress.com/2022/02/21/thomas-william-kirk-1883-1966/
- John Kirk was an inmate at Birmingham Reformatory Institution in 1901 and at 19 Weathill Street (Rotherham) in 1911 with his remarried mother. He was still at 19 Weathill Street (and a miner) when he married Florence Emily Barker of Putney (Surrey) in 1915 in Putney. John (a school attendance officer) and Florence were at Clifton Avenue (Rotherham) in 1921 and at 140 Badsley Moor Lane (Rotherham) in 1939.
I have written about John and Florence at https://birdsofcressingham.wordpress.com/2022/02/07/how-did-john-kirk-from-rotherham-meet-florence-barker-in-putney/
Less likely to be Isabella’s father is John and Thomas William Kirk’s older brother William Robert Kirk (1868-1945), already married in 1895. https://birdsofcressingham.wordpress.com/2022/01/14/william-robert-kirk-1868-1945/
When Isabella Parkin was conceived, Thomas William was about 18, John was about 15 and William Robert was about 33. Given their ages, Thomas William seems the most likely candidate
Conclusions
It seems likely that Isabella Parkin’s father was Thomas William Kirk or possibly his younger brother John Kirk. If so, Isabella’s was my father’s 1st cousin.
It would be useful to find more DNA evidence tying Isabella to ancestors of my great grandparents Robert Kirk and Ann Guest.

